Kieran Healy

Posted
18 April 2006 @ 3pm

Tagged
Misc

Name that Scheme

You sometimes see a rhetorical device were the author compares himself (or another) to some related group of people, real or fictional, and says that while one might have hoped to be x, it turns out one is actually y. So, for example, here’s one inspired by reading Untold Stories the other night. “When I was younger I hoped I might be Peter Cook, or even Jonathan Miller, but then I discovered I was really Alan Bennett.” As can be seen from this example, there is usually a strong element of faux-modest self-promotion in the apparent putdown, at least when the author is the subject of the comparison. When there is some other target, this scheme is a vehicle for insult. In these cases, the comparison individuals will be related not by a substantive tie but only by name.


One-Liners As You Know, Darth, the Galaxy …